Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council

Application Type FULL PERMISSION	Status Appeal Decided - Allowed
Case Officer Ms Kirsty Shirley	Case Officer Email k.shirley@welhat.gov.uk
Location 11 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	Proposal Conversion and extension to existing dwelling to create four self-contained units with associated infrastructure
Easting 530503	Northing 202806
Ward Northaw and Cuffley	Ward Members Councillor Bernard Sarson Councillor George Michaelides Councillor Barbara Fitzsimon
Parish Northaw and Cuffley	UPRN 100080970478
Date Received 17/02/2023	Date Valid 20/02/2023
Advert Expiry Date	Consultation Expiry Date 20/03/2023
Site Notice Expiry Date 28/03/2023
Agent Mrs Helen Kyprianos	Applicant Sonar Group Ltd
Agent's Address 198 High Street Barnet EN5 5SZ	Applicant's Address c/o agent

Description	Distance
Parish	0.00
Article 4 Direction Misc (inc Walls, Gates, Gardens)	0.00
Flood Zone Surface Water 30mm	0.00
Flood Zone Surface Water 100mm	0.00
Flood Zone Surface Water 100mm	0.00
Flood Zone Surface Water 1000mm	0.00
Hertfordshire Ecological Network	0.00
Sand and Gravel Belt	0.00

View the location of this application on an Ordnance Survey map

Decision

Refused

Decision Date

14/04/2023

Issue Date

14/04/2023

Decision Level

Delegated

Committee Date

Please click the appeal number to view further details.

Appeal Number	Status / Decision	Decision date
6/2023/0374/FULL	Appeal Allowed with Conditions	01/02/2024

To download a selection of individual documents place a tick alongside each of the relevant rows and then click on Download selected files. To download all of the documents place a tick in the box alongside the header row and all of the files will be selected, then click on Download selected files. To view individual documents click on the File for the required row.

Select All

Select All	File	Description	Date Uploaded
Application Form - Without Personal Information
	File: ApplicationFormRedacted.pdf (414 kb)	Description: Applicationformredacted	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Block Plan
	File: P.05 Site Plans.pdf (555 kb)	Description: Site Plans	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Elevations
	File: P.03 Proposed Elevations & Sections.pdf (172 kb)	Description: Proposed Elevations & Sections	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Floor Plans
	File: P.01 Proposed Layout.pdf (467 kb)	Description: Proposed Layout	Created Date: 17/02/2023
	File: P.02 Proposed Layout.pdf (180 kb)	Description: Proposed Layout	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Location Plan
	File: P.06_11 Tolmers Gardens-LP.01.pdf (142 kb)	Description: Location Plan	Created Date: 20/02/2023
Plans
	File: Ex.01 Existing plans and elevations.pdf (322 kb)	Description: Existing Plans, Elevations & Sections	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Street Scene
	File: P.04 Streetscape.pdf (155 kb)	Description: Streetscape	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Consultee Response
	File: Comments.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Comment - WHBC - Client Services	Created Date: 28/02/2023
	File: FW_ 6_2023_0374.pdf (188 kb)	Description: Call in - Cllr Michaelides	Created Date: 14/03/2023
	File: WK136934 - 11 Tolmers Gardens.pdf (68 kb)	Description: Comments - WHBC Public Health and Protection	Created Date: 14/03/2023
	File: Comments(1).pdf (73 kb)	Description: Conditional response - WHBC - Public Health and Protection	Created Date: 14/03/2023
	File: Response_6-2023-0374-FULL.pdf (72 kb)	Description: Objection - HCC Highways	Created Date: 21/03/2023
	File: Comments(2).pdf (76 kb)	Description: Major Objection- Northaw & Cuffley Parish Council	Created Date: 29/03/2023
Neighbour Representation - Without Personal Information
	File: New comments for application 6_2023_0374_FULL_Redacted.pdf (99 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	Created Date: 06/03/2023
	File: FW_ Application Reference_ 6_2023_0374_FULL_Redacted.pdf (155 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 4 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	Created Date: 06/03/2023
	File: Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 07-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (71 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 07/03/2023
	File: Planning permission 11 Tolmers gardens March 2023_Redacted.pdf (98 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -attachment Redacted	Created Date: 08/03/2023
	File: WHC No 11 Tolmers Gardens_Redacted.pdf (404 kb)	Description: Objection - 10 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -attachment Redacted	Created Date: 10/03/2023
	File: 10 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 10-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (72 kb)	Description: Objection - 10 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 10/03/2023
	File: Document against 11 Tolmers Gardens planning application March 23.pdf (1829 kb)	Description: Objection- Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Wy Evidence against No 11 Redacted	Created Date: 13/03/2023
	File: Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 11-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection-Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 11/03/2023
	File: Flat 4, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, EN6 4JE Objection 11-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (74 kb)	Description: Objection-Flat 4, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 11/03/2023
	File: OBJECTION FOR PLANNING APPLICATION- 11 TOLMERS GARDENS.pdf (216 kb)	Description: Objection- Former 12 Tolmers Gardens- OBJECTION FOR PLANNING APPLICATION 6/2023/0374/FULL	Created Date: 12/03/2023
	File: ALLOCATED PARKING SPACES AT 12 TOLMERS GARDENS.pdf (2187 kb)	Description: Objection-Former 12 Tolmers Gardens-ALLOCATED PARKING SPACES AT 12 TOLMERS GARDENS	Created Date: 12/03/2023
	File: Reaction on developer statements for planning application for 11 Tolmers Gardens March 2023.pdf (3737 kb)	Description: Objection comments - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens	Created Date: 15/03/2023
	File: Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 15-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (74 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 15/03/2023
	File: Reaction on developer statements for planning application for 11 Tolmers Gardens March 2023 (1).pdf (3737 kb)	Description: Objection comments - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens	Created Date: 15/03/2023
	File: Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 15-03-2023-Redacted(1).pdf (74 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 15/03/2023
	File: Fwd_ RE_ Planning App. Ref_ 6_2023_0374_FULL_Redacted.pdf (330 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens EN6 4JE - redacted	Created Date: 16/03/2023
	File: Flat 8, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 16-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 16/03/2023
	File: Flat 7, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 16-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 7 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 16/03/2023
	File: Flat 7, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 16-03-2023-Redacted(1).pdf (72 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 7 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 16/03/2023
	File: Comparison of planning application of 11 Tolmers gardens 2023 to 2022_opt.pdf (890 kb)	Description: Objection comments - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens	Created Date: 17/03/2023
	File: Flat 5, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 17-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 17/03/2023
	File: Tolmers Gardens Planning_Redacted.pdf (285 kb)	Description: Objection comments - Flat 3 12 Tolmers Gardens - redacted	Created Date: 20/03/2023
	File: Flat 3, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4JE Objection 19-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 3 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE -Redacted	Created Date: 19/03/2023
	File: FW_ Planning App. Ref_ 6_2023_0374_FULL_Redacted.pdf (269 kb)	Description: Objection - Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar - redacted	Created Date: 20/03/2023
	File: 115 Brookside Crescent, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4QP Objection 20-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - 115 Brookside Crescent Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4QP -Redacted	Created Date: 20/03/2023
	File: OBJECTION 12 Tolmers Gardens_Redacted.pdf (86 kb)	Description: Objection - 6 Highfields Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4EL - Comments - redacted	Created Date: 21/03/2023
	File: 6 Highfields, Cuffley, Potters Bar, EN6 4EL Objection 20-03-2023-Redacted.pdf (73 kb)	Description: Objection - 6 Highfields Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4EL -Redacted	Created Date: 20/03/2023
Photographs
	File: Site Photos_Redacted.pdf (12806 kb)	Description: Site Photos_Redacted	Created Date: 17/02/2023
Decision Notice PDF
	File: Decision Notice_620230374FULL.pdf (25 kb)	Description: Decision Notice	Created Date: 14/04/2023
Officer Report PDF
	File: Delegated Report_620230374FULL(7).pdf (55 kb)	Description: Delegated Report	Created Date: 14/04/2023
Site Notice
	File: Site Notice_620230374FULL.pdf (85 kb)	Description: Site Notice	Created Date: 07/03/2023
Supporting Information
	File: 11 Tolmers Gardens_ PN_Redacted.pdf (1704 kb)	Description: Planning Note - Redacted	Created Date: 10/03/2023
	File: form_1_cil_additional_information.pdf (250 kb)	Description: CIL Form	Created Date: 10/03/2023

Organisation	Name	Sent	Reply Due	Reply Received
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor Bernard Sarson	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor Bernard Sarson	14/04/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor Gail Ganney	14/04/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor Gail Ganney	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor George Michaelides	27/02/2023	20/03/2023	14/03/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Councillor George Michaelides	14/04/2023
Hertfordshire County Council	Hertfordshire Transport Programmes & Strategy	14/04/2023
Hertfordshire County Council	Hertfordshire Transport Programmes & Strategy	27/02/2023	20/03/2023	20/03/2023
WHBC - Client Services	Lorraine Davis	14/04/2023
WHBC - Client Services	Lorraine Davis	27/02/2023	20/03/2023	28/02/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Parking Services	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council	Parking Services	14/04/2023
WHBC - Public Health and Protection	Public Health and Protection	14/04/2023
WHBC - Public Health and Protection	Public Health and Protection	27/02/2023	20/03/2023	14/03/2023
Northaw & Cuffley Parish Council	The Clerk	14/04/2023
Northaw & Cuffley Parish Council	The Clerk	27/02/2023	20/03/2023	29/03/2023

Address	Date Sent	Expiry Date
Flat 4, 12 Tolmers Gardens, Cuffley, EN6 4JE
115 Brookside Crescent Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4QP
6 Highfields Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4EL
10 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Former 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
24 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
25 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Cuffley Hall Maynard Place Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JA	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Cuffley Library Maynard Place Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JA	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 1 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 2 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 3 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 4 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 5 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 6 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 7 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 7 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE
Flat 8 12 Tolmers Gardens Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JE	27/02/2023	20/03/2023
Gp Practice Maynard Place Cuffley Potters Bar EN6 4JA	27/02/2023	20/03/2023

Application Number	Proposal	Decision	Distance
6/2024/1960/FULL	Erection of a two storey side/rear extension and single storey rear extension, new enlarged roof, and loft conversion to facilitate conversion into 5 x 1-bedroom units. Associated landscaping and access, and provision of parking with associated alterations to the parking layout for 12 Tolmers Gardens.		0
6/2024/0769/COND	Submission of details pursuant to condition number 4 (crown roof),5 (materials),6 (landscaping scheme),7 (refuse and recycling store and the cycle store),8 (allocation of car parking),9 (external lighting),10 (obscured glazing) on planning permission 6/2023/0374/FULL/ Appeal ref: APP/C1950/W/23/3323499	Granted	0
6/2023/0374/FULL	Conversion and extension to existing dwelling to create four self-contained units with associated infrastructure	Appeal Allowed with Conditions
6/2022/0922/FULL	Conversion and extension to existing single dwelling house to create 4x 1 bed apartments with associated infrastructure	Refused	0
6/2020/2944/VAR	Variation of condition 14 (approved plans) on planning permission 6/2018/3125/FULL	Granted	0
6/2019/3216/COND	Submission of details pursuant to condition 1 (sample of materials) 2 (crown roof details) 3 (scheme of accessible housing) 4 (balcony flank screens) 5 (hard and soft landscaping works) 7 (cycle store) 8 (bin store) and 9 (shared surface access) on planning permission 6/2018/3125/FULL	Granted	0
6/2019/2776/VAR	Removal of condition 9 (shared surface access) on planning permission 6/2018/3125/FULL	Withdrawn	0
6/2018/3125/FULL	Erection of 8 x apartments following demolition of existing bungalow	Granted	0
6/2017/0474/FULL	Erection of two semi-detached 4-bedroomed dwellings with associated car parking and landscaping, following the demolition of existing bungalow.	Refused	0
6/2015/2333/FULL	Erection of 5 new dwellings and shop (Use Class A5) with new access following demolition of shed and two garages	Granted	0
S6/1991/0452/FP	Siting of textile bank	Granted	1
S6/1985/0619/FP	Two storey rear extension	Granted	0
S6/1981/0708/	Single storey side extension	Granted	0
S6/1980/0456/	Single storey side, front and rear extensions	Granted	0
S6/1979/0410/	Two storey rear extension	Granted	0
S6/1979/0741/	Ground floor rear extension and new dormer	Granted	0

There are no NMAs associated with this application

Planning Application: 6/2023/0374/FULL